Understanding self-insurance in trucking
In trucking, risk is part of the business, and most carriers manage liability through traditional insurance policies. For a small number of companies, self-insurance is an alternative. This article covers what it takes for a trucking company to be self-insured and the financial responsibilities that come with it.
Being a self-insured trucking company means assuming the financial risk of losses and liabilities that an insurance policy would normally cover. Instead of paying premiums to an insurer, the company sets aside funds to pay claims for accidents, damage or other liabilities directly.
A motor carrier can't simply decide to self-insure. Self-insurance requires approval from the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration (FMCSA) under 49 CFR 387.309. Without that approval, the carrier must carry the insurance or surety coverage the regulations require.
Self-insuring takes detailed analysis and planning. A company needs the internal staff and systems to manage claims, legal proceedings and the financial contingencies that come with operating commercial vehicles. Some carriers choose it for more control over claims handling and potential cost differences, but it also takes a serious commitment to safety, compliance and financial management.
Requirements for a self-insured trucking company
A trucking company that wants to self-insure must meet the criteria FMCSA sets out in 49 CFR 387.309. Read the regulation itself for the full requirements; the main areas are summarized below.
Financial condition
The company must show it has the financial standing to cover claims itself. The application includes a true and accurate statement of the company's financial condition, which FMCSA reviews against the size of the operation and the level of self-insurance requested.
A sound self-insurance program
The company must have a sound self-insurance program that provides security at least equal to the minimum limits that would otherwise apply to it. The company must also have an adequate safety program: a current "satisfactory" safety rating, or a certification that it has not been rated. An application from a carrier with a less than satisfactory rating is denied, and self-insurance authority expires 30 days after a carrier receives a less than satisfactory rating. FMCSA may ask for additional information to support the application (49 CFR 387.309(a)).
Responsibilities of a self-insured trucking company
A self-insured trucking company is responsible for paying covered claims, such as bodily injury and property damage, out of its own resources. That calls for an active approach to risk management, which may include setting aside reserves, establishing trust funds or arranging other financial backing so that claims can be paid.
Becoming self-insured is not a decision to take lightly. It takes careful planning and strict adherence to FMCSA regulations. If you're weighing insurance options for a new or growing carrier, see our page on commercial truck insurance.
Form BMC-40: application for authority to self-insure
The application to self-insure under 49 U.S.C. 13906 is FMCSA Form BMC-40. You can find it on FMCSA's website: Form BMC-40.
Sources and further reading
Logistical Forwarding Solutions. A carrier-first company.




